Tudor Black Bay new vs Rolex Explorer II pre-owned

[Wafflelee]

depreciation ,looks

The new blk bay will depreciate faster then a used Exp 2. My guess we may see old blk bays stabliise just above the 3K mark next year, 2014. A newer exp 2 will stabilise at between 4.5 to 5K. The exp 2 movement (3186) found in the M & V series is very good, far superior to the eta in a blk bay. Buy the blk bay if you like the feel of being the first owner and its looks = or buy the Exp 2 and own a solid dependable watch. Btw, Exp2 has two time zones, great for travel and overseas work.

[rsub99]

Buy both then. My vote for Tudor Black Bay.

[lefty]

Like most comments here, if this is your first Rolex, then get the Rolex first (budget permitting)

While Black Bay is a dive watch, the Explorer 2 is a dual time zone.

Ever considered a 14060? it's a closer comparo to the Black Bay (both being dive watches). You may find pre-own pieces starting from $4k+ onwards too.

[Ymc]

This would be my second. I got a DJ.

I'm basically going for looks and affordability here. Bang for buck. Lol.

Nope I don't want to get the Submariner. It's a great watch and I know it's Rolex icon but it's just too common. Every one has got one.

[R-oyster]

I think you are looking for a watch which could be an investment. I think the Exp 2 is a better choice, because Rolex has a better resale value. So go for the Exp 2 rather than the Tudor Black Bay.

[lefty]

This would be my second. I got a DJ.

I'm basically going for looks and affordability here. Bang for buck. Lol.

Nope I don't want to get the Submariner. It's a great watch and I know it's Rolex icon but it's just too common. Every one has got one.

Given the above considerations, i'll go for a "t-dial" 16570 with nice patina and matching hands. White or black dial wld just be as nice and exquisite. Good luck on your search!

[ahken]

Both are good catch!